Wind Systems Magazine

April 23, 2014

Share

RELATED ARTICLES

Effective Lubrication Filtration

Clean lubricants are critical to allowing your gearbox to...

 

Wind Farms and Cranes: A Long-Term Relationship

Crane operators provide essential services to wind farm...

 

MAINTENANCE

Once your warranty period has drawn to a close, inadequate...

 

Inspecting Gears for Wind

The new 3000GM analytical gear inspection system from...

 

An Online Communications Solution

Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) systems provide...

 

Forest Sites Demand a Differentiated Approach

Alternative turbine location sites in Germany have...

 

MAINTENANCE

How your turbine is handled prior to going online can take...

 

Increasing Uptime with Remote Monitoring

According to Schenck Balancing & Diagnostic Systems, the...

 

Wind Turbine Capacity Frontier From SCADA

The wind industry is experiencing rapid growth across the...

 

The Mobile Age of Service Technology

Like it or not the mobile age is here, and wind turbine...

 

TECHNOLOGY

The challenges involved in building-integrated wind energy...

 

MAINTENANCE

Consider the multiple benefits of condition monitoring...

 

Optimized Wind Farm Operation and Maintenance

The challenges of selecting an O&M service provider in a...

 

Company Profile: Shermco Industries

From the nacelle down to the substation, this company...

 

Monitoring Rotating Machinery

Keeping an eye on the health of your wind turbine rotating...

 

Inspecting Gears for Wind

The new 3000GM analytical gear inspection system from...

 

MAINTENANCE

To be proficient in managing your maintenance plan, it...

 

Company Profile: Gearbox Express

Gearbox Express is fulfilling a niche the wind power...

 

MAINTENANCE

The generator is the heart of the windmill power generation...

 

Maximizing Wind Energy Yield

Wind farm operators want to make sure their turbines are...

 

Optical Ice Sensors for Wind Turbine Nacelles

New optical technology borrowed from the communications...

 

Advances in Remote Monitoring

The SKF WindCon turbine monitoring system provides...

 

Company Profile: LUDECA, Inc.

Combining easy-to-use components, site services, and a...

 

A Model for Offshore Innovation

As offshore development begins in the United States,...

 

Optimal Tower and Foundation Design

A new measure of wind tower scalability for greater hub...

 

Data Drives Offshore Development

First-generation wind projects off the U.S. coastline...

 

Making Wind Even More Cost Competitive

An examination of wind turbine costs through alternatives...

 

Renting Aerials for Inspection & Maintenance

Increase productivity and safety in multi-tower...

 

The Winds of Innovation

The wind turbine industry has emerged as a driving force...

 

InSight Helps Wind Asset Owners Manage Operations

Software improves return on assets by identifying,...

 

Increasing Generator Lifespan

Not only can upgrades drastically increase the service life...

 

Monitoring for Maintenance

The experts at Turningpoint explain why you can think of...

 

TECHNOLOGY

Next-generation wind turbines will be smarter, more...

 

Are Transient Events Damaging Your Turbine’s Drivetrain?

Searching for the root causes of White Etch Area damage and...

 

MAINTENANCE

Despite sophisticated control systems on modern wind...

 

Archives > April 2013 > Managing Drivetrain Health: Knowledge is Power, Time is Money

Managing Drivetrain Health: Knowledge is Power, Time is Money

By: Larry Jacobs

 

Stretching your O&M budget can be achieved by properly and systematically processing the data derived from condition monitoring equipment.

 

As the U.S. wind industry transitions to a larger install base of turbines that are either out of warranty or soon to be, the focus of every owner/operator turns to optimizing their operations and maintenance and more specifically, managing the health of the drivetrain and its components. The cost of failures as it relates to drivetrain components can quickly erode an O&M budget—especially if these failures were not anticipated or if they occur within a timeframe that was not expected. Drivetrain health management is the key to understanding the existing condition of drivetrain components as it provides effective failure mode prediction (not just fault detection) and it allows for well-timed planning of maintenance activities.

The English philosopher Sir Francis Bacon has been credited with the phrase, “knowledge is power”. This is never more appropriate when it comes to drivetrain health management and failure mode prediction. This knowledge comes from two sources—the knowledge that a health management system provides to the end user and even more importantly, the knowledge, expertise, and experience that went into developing such a system. There is a ton of data that can be generated by health management systems such as condition monitoring, lubrication sampling, oil particle counters, SCADA, etc., but the true value of these systems lies with the processing and analysis of this data. Romax InSight software combines all these various health management tools into one system (Table 1) and InSight services provides the engineering know-how to implement processes, re-engineer components or develop retrofit modifications to reduce failures. Grease sampling is a common monitoring technique for large bearings, and Romax InSight iDS software provides tools to trend grease ferrography and elemental composition results; yet as shown in Figure 1, without implementation of proper sampling procedures the monitoring can be erroneous. This result is included in procedures developed for technicians to illustrate why to sample a certain way.

Sidebar 1

The “Maintenance Scheduling” sidebar (p. 39) shows the progression of main bearing failure where the specialized analysis implemented within the InSight software provides at least six months prediction on failure. Having this knowledge well in advance of the pending failure is equally important to managing drivetrain health. Figure 2 looks at the optimal time to perform maintenance as it relates to three maintenance models. The preventive model results in high cost of maintenance with low cost of failure. Reactive maintenance results in a low cost of maintenance with high cost of failure. The intersection of these two modes is predictive maintenance and is determined to be the optimal maintenance time. However, it should be noted that this optimal time is not necessarily a one-size-fits-all model. Having the information of a failure mode (knowledge is power) well in advance of the pending fault (time is money) puts the owner/operator in the driver’s seat for scheduling the maintenance activity and allows for well-informed decisions. It provides flexibility on when to order parts, resource availability, and when to deploy a crane (if needed); and these may not always align with the “optimal” maintenance time.

So, when we say “optimizing O&M” what do we really mean? It means optimizing production—ensuring turbines are available when the wind is blowing and ensuring turbines are operating at peak performance. It also means minimizing operational costs through balancing cost of maintenance with cost of failure (as shown in Figure 2).  When we take these into consideration with the understanding that time is money, then the objectives for any maintenance related activity is to schedule during low wind seasons (ideally), and when labor and equipment is available, and at most reasonable cost. 

Sidebar 2

Field experience is important in developing effective and reliable analysis tools  (See “Failure Cause Analysis,” p. 38). Root cause analysis and field inspections of drivetrain failures provide important feedback in validating analysis techniques. We all want to find the needle in a haystack so practical experience is just as valuable. With drivetrain health management there are many factors to consider when determining the best solutions—size of the wind farm, size and age of the turbines, installed condition monitoring hardware, and component failure rates. These are all considerations in determining what’s best. Ideally, a well-established continuous monitoring program is in place and a historical database is being established. But in cases where CMS hardware is not yet installed what are my options? As an example, Figure 3outlines some tools and techniques to consider when establishing a drivetrain health management program for main bearing failures. Figure 4


When it comes to reducing risk with knowledge and time, and turbine O&M cost savings, the long-term benefits of a health management program are clearly measureable—prevent catastrophic events, convert downtower repair/replacement into an uptower repair, effectively manage spare parts inventory, curtail operations for prolonged production, mitigate insurance risks, and amortize equipment costs. 

 

 

About The Author
Larry Jacobs

is the marketing and sales manager, North America, for Romax Technology. He can be reached at 802.858.9185 or larry.jacobs@romaxtech.com. Visit Romax at WINDPOWER 2013, Booth 2909.

 

 

Wind Systems is a trademark of Media Solutions, Inc, copyright 2002-2010.

Wind Systems and all contents are properties of Media Solutions, Inc.